Questioning the latest headlines: Does vitamin D supplementation improve bone density?

Posted on: August 20, 2015   by  John Cannell, MD

img

A recent randomized controlled trial (RCT) published in Journal of the American Medical Association made headlines throughout the world, with experts being quoted as advising older women to only take 600 to 800 IU/day.

Many Older Women Don’t Need Vitamin D Supplements

Let’s look at the study in depth: 230 postmenopausal women with baseline 25(OH)D levels between 14 and 27 ng/ml were randomized into one of three groups: placebo, 800 IU/day or 50,000 IU every two weeks. The women received the assigned treatment for one year. The primary end point was total fractional calcium absorption (TFCA) from the intestine. Bone mineral density was a secondary end point as were muscle function, muscle mass, trabecular bone score, bone turnover, pain, functional status, and physical activity.

Hansen KE, Johnson RE, Chambers KR, Johnson MG, Lemon CC, Vo TN, Marvdashti S. Treatment of Vitamin D Insufficiency in Postmenopausal Women: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Intern Med. 2015 Aug 3.

Contrary to the news stories, that primary endpoint was positive; that is, the women on high dose vitamin D (50,000 IU every two weeks) had better calcium absorption. The study showed TFCA increased 1% in the high-dose arm but decreased 2% in the low-dose arm (P = .005 vs high-dose arm) and decreased 1.3% in the placebo arm (P = .03 vs high-dose arm).

Although this difference is not large, osteoporosis takes decades to develop. Would you rather have improved calcium absorption or worsened calcium absorption for the rest of your life? Remember, this study took place for only one year, not one decade.

However, the only secondary end point that was positive in the high dose group was femoral neck bone mineral density, and that disappeared with adjustment. These findings were indeed disappointing.

It’s important to take a closer look at the study design. The low dose group took 800 IU/day, but the high dose group took 50,000 IU every two weeks. Why? Large doses every two weeks are physiologically different than higher daily dosing. Since the researchers had one group taking vitamin D daily, the other groups should have also received a daily pill. This may explain why the secondary endpoints were not met.

My next observation is that the researchers did not conduct a subgroup analysis. Did the women who had lower baseline 25(OH)D levels respond any differently than the women who had higher baseline levels? The authors could have easily done such an analysis, but did not publish it if they did.

Finally, no one I know says vitamin D alone will prevent or treat osteoporosis. It is a complex disease with many nutrients (and drugs) involved in both its prevention and treatment. For example, a RCT found vitamin K helped bone indices.

Koitaya N, Sekiguchi M, Tousen Y, Nishide Y, Morita A, Yamauchi J, Gando Y, Miyachi M, Aoki M, Komatsu M, Watanabe F, Morishita K, Ishimi Y. Low-dose vitamin K2 (MK-4) supplementation for 12 months improves bone metabolism and prevents forearm bone loss in postmenopausal Japanese women. J Bone Miner Metab. 2014 Mar;32(2):142-50.

Likewise, a RCT of magnesium showed it helped bone health.

Carpenter TO, DeLucia MC, Zhang JH, Bejnerowicz G, Tartamella L, Dziura J, Petersen KF, Befroy D, Cohen D. A randomized controlled study of effects of dietary magnesium oxide supplementation on bone mineral content in healthy girls. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2006 Dec;91(12):4866-72.

For these reasons, we recommend Bio Tech’s D3- K2 along with their magnesium carbonate. Also, eat your vegetables, exercise regularly and keep your blood sodium from becoming low.

3 Responses to Questioning the latest headlines: Does vitamin D supplementation improve bone density?

  1. Rita Celone Umile

    Dr. Cannell, thank you for explaining this study.
    The news stories were so negative I wondered if big pharma had somehow slanted the media reports. After all, pharma does have a vested interested.

    Moving on….

    Regarding the study, in my opinion, 50,000 iu D3 every 2 weeks isn’t an adequate dose. 10,000 iu D3 daily might have yielded much more interesting results (again in my opinion).

  2. gatorbabe195246102800

    My Vitamin D level has been on the low side
    of the scale ever since my breast cancer in
    2011. After that, it was still a struggle to
    get the level to increase. When my level
    dropped to 4.94, the doctors office raised
    my Rx Vitamin D, it took making the decision
    to add Vitamin K along with it to achieve
    results. In a two month window, my Vitamin
    D level jumped from 4.94 to 90.12.

    • John Cannell, MD

      That’s amazing. To my knowledge, that has never been studied.

Test Your Vitamin D Levels at Home!

Our in-home Vitamin D Test Kit is easy, affordable, and an accurate way to find out your Vitamin D status.

order NOW

We need your help!

We're spreading awareness on Vitamin D Deficiency
Donate NOW
Latest Articles
img
Vitamin D supplementation may provide relief for patients with atopic dermatitis

A recently published meta-analysis proves that vitamin D supplementation is a safe and effective treatment for atopic dermatitis.

Weekly Newsletter