Asked by rockyecheverria91766700 on July 6, 2016
IAW on July 7, 2016 at 6:30 am
Rocky I am not a doctor but will give you my best suggestions.
First what kind of magnesium are you taking? If it is Oxide it does not absorb the best and I would switch to a different kind. Second how much do you take? Your symptoms sound more like a magnesium problem BUT anything is possible. So you may want to experiment and take more magnesium first and see if that cures the problem.
If it does not help then, yes I would try calcium especially since you say there might not be enough in your diet. You could try an amount that would equal 500mg between your diet and a supplement. (Point is you probably do not need to take 1000mg.)
Then if you would be so kind, come back and let me know which (if any) worked. (If it turns out to be the calcium and not magnesium, I really would like to know.)Answered by IAW on July 7, 2016 at 6:30 am
rockyecheverria91766700 on July 7, 2016 at 10:15 am
I have chelated magnesium, aspartate, and glycinate. I do eat 2 cups of Greek yogurt a day, which yields 500 mg calcium. I’m going to lay off the D for awhile. The cardiovascular side effects were starting to really bother me. I may start up again after I feel better. This has happened before. It takes about a week or 2 for these sides to dissipate. When I restart I will implement a protocol that hopefully works. I’m thinking 1,000 IU’s D3, K2, dry A, 600 mg magnesium, and an additional 500 mg calcium so that I get 1000/day via food and supplement. Does this sound adequate?Answered by rockyecheverria91766700 on July 7, 2016 at 10:15 am
IAW on July 7, 2016 at 11:47 am
You neglected to answer the “how much magnesium do you take right now”? The RDA is around 400 but the VDC makes the statement that “Some research studies show that your body needs between 500 and 700 mg a day.” (Worse case scenario is if you take too much, you will have “loose bowels” and then will have to decrease the amount.)
Vitamin D helps calcium to absorb from your digestive system.
I am not trying to get personal but do you take ANY medications and/or have any health issues? (It might give me another reason for your symptoms happening with the “D”.)Answered by IAW on July 7, 2016 at 11:47 am
IAW on July 7, 2016 at 4:48 pm
I don’t know if this is just a matter of “wording” but you said “I WAS taking 600mg”. Since you stopped the D, did you also stop the magnesium? I hope not. You should take it whether or not you are taking the D right now.
So I think your plan for 1000iu Vitamin D, 500 supplemental calcium and yes I would try and increase the magnesium over 600mg to see if that helps. If things go well, then I hope you can eventually increase the amount of Vitamin D you take.
Sometimes I wonder if someone is deficient in Vitamin D, if quite possible they may need higher amounts of some of these minerals and vitamins so their bodies can do “extra” repair work. Then maybe later if they hit some kind of equilibrium, then maybe they will not need quite as much. It is just a thought! So if you take some extra magnesium and calcium it may get you over some kind of “hump” and then later you will not need to take as much.
Vitamin D uses a lot of magnesium to process things!Answered by IAW on July 7, 2016 at 4:48 pm
rockyecheverria91766700 on July 8, 2016 at 3:35 pm
I’m still taking 500 mg magnesium chelate and aspartate/day. I bumped it to 700 today. Haven’t taken D3 in supplement form for 2 days. Still feeling some sides, but I get 200 IU’s/day from my multi and I consume 6 whole eggs/day, which yields another 400 IU’s or soAnswered by rockyecheverria91766700 on July 8, 2016 at 3:35 pm